Steven Yeun character Bo (voice)
Keegan-Michael Key character Dave (voice)
Aidy Bryant character Ruth (voice)
Oprah Winfrey character Deborah (voice)
Tyler Perry character Cyrus (voice)
Gina Rodriguez character Mary (voice)
Zachary Levi character Joseph (voice)
Kelly Clarkson character Leah (voice)
Christopher Plummer character King Herod (voice)
Tracy Morgan character Felix (voice)
Kristin Chenoweth character Abby (voice)
Anthony Anderson character Zach (voice)
Ving Rhames character Thaddeus (voice)
Gabriel Iglesias character Rufus (voice)
Patricia Heaton character Edith (voice)
Kris Kristofferson character Old Donkey (voice)
Mariah Carey character Rebecca (voice)
Fred Tatasciore character Melchior / Inn keeper #1 / Pottery Vendor (voice)
Kari Wahlgren character Additional Voices (voice)
Gregg Berger character Inn Keeper #3 (voice)
Joel Osteen character Caspar (voice)
Lex Lang character Hunter (voice)
Roger Craig Smith character Chamberlain / Inn Keeper #5 (voice)
William Townsend character Horse / Goat (voice)
Stephen Apostolina character Additional Voices (voice)
Kirk Baily character Additional Voices (voice)
David Cowgill character Additional Voices (voice)
June Christopher character Additional Voices (voice)
Eddie Frierson character Additional Voices (voice)
Rif Hutton character Additional Voices (voice)
Mona Marshall character Additional Voices (voice)
Caitlin McKenna-Wilkinson character Additional Voices (voice)
Scott Menville character Additional Voices (voice)
Warren Sroka character Additional Voices (voice)
Pepper Sweeney character Additional Voices (voice)
Grant George character Additional Voices (voice)
Bridget Hoffman character Additional Voices (voice)
Moira Quirk character Additional Voices (voice)
Michelle Ruff character Additional Voices (voice)
Joseph Sanfelippo character Additional Voices (voice)
Justin Shenkarow character Additional Voices (voice)
