Jonah Hill character Michael Finkel
James Franco character Christian Longo
Felicity Jones character Jill Barker
Maria Dizzia character Mary Jane Longo
Ethan Suplee character Pat Frato
Robert John Burke character Greg Ganley
Charlotte Driscoll character Sadie Longo
Kohl Sudduth character Police Officer
Conor Kikot character Zach Longo
Stella Rae Payne character Madison Longo
Byron Jennings character Judge Odenkirk
Gretchen Mol character Karen
Betty Gilpin character Cheryl
Seth Barrish character Blaise
Robert Stanton character Jeffrey Gregg
Michael Countryman character Coroner
Steve Routman character Jack Pool
Genevieve Angelson character Tina Alvis
Adam Mucci character Courtroom Sheriff
David Wilson Barnes character Corey Douglas
William Jackson Harper character Zak Rausch
Sam Rosen character Steve Mensah
Mara Hobel character Jail Receptionist
David Pittu character Marcus Lickermann
Auden Thornton character Lena
Ngo Okafor character Ibrahim
Uchenna Onuaguluchi character Madou
Maryann Plunkett character Maureen Duffy
Joseph Harrell character Visiting Room Guard #1
Mike Houston character Visiting Room Guard #2
Rosemary Howard character Jury Forewoman
Joel Garland character Dan Pegg
Dana Eskelson character Joy Longo
Peter Francis James character Colin Parker
Edward James Hyland character Mr. Longo
Johanna Day character Beth Tickler
Georgia Ford character Young Woman
Loudon Wainwright III character Older Man
Julie Sharbutt character Female MSU Worker
Eleanor Hutchins character Middle-Aged Woman
Rebecca Henderson character Ellen Parks
Jay Ferraro character Geoffrey J. Ploobtark
