Anya Taylor-Joy character Thomasin
Ralph Ineson character William
Kate Dickie character Katherine
Harvey Scrimshaw character Caleb
Ellie Grainger character Mercy
Lucas Dawson character Jonas
Bathsheba Garnett character The Witch
Sarah Stephens character The Witch, young
Julian Richings character Governor
Wahab Chaudhry character Black Phillip (voice)
Axtun Henry Dube character Samuel
Athan Conrad Dube character Samuel
Vivien Moore character Lead Coven Witch
Karen Kaeja character Coven Witch
Brandy Leary character Coven Witch
R. Hope Terry character Coven Witch
Carrie Eklund character Coven Witch
Madlen Sopadzhiyan character Coven Witch
Paul Kenworthy character Militia Man 1
Mark Millmna character Militia Man 2
Andy Volpe character Militia Man 3
Phillip Wynne character Wampanoag Man
Annawon Weeden character Wampanoag Man
Michael O'Hare character Pipe Smoker
Chris Messier character Shepherd
Ron Young character Old Slater
Nora Messier character Shepherdess
Bill Rudder character Settler
Grace Duffy character Settler
Sophie Bermudez character Settler
Corrine Manning character Settler
Heather Fisher character Chamber Pot Woman
