Audra McDonald character Herself
Darren Criss character Frank
Jeremy Jordan character Charley
America Ferrera character Mary / Herself
Stephen Sondheim character Himself / Joe
Jarvis Cocker character Crooner
Yvonne De Carlo character Herself (archive footage)
Jackie Hoffman character Singer #17
Dean Jones character Himself (archive footage)
Angela Lansbury character Mrs. Lovett (archive footage)
Bette Midler character Mama Rose (archive footage)
Laura Osnes character Beth
Barbara Barrie character Herself (archive footage)
Charles Braswell character Himself (archive footage)
Susan Browning character Herself (archive footage)
Judy Bruno Bennett character Former Flapper
Glenn Close character Herself (archive footage)
George Coe character Himself (archive footage)
John Cunningham character Himself (archive footage)
Judi Dench character Herself (archive footage)
Steve Elmore character Himself (archive footage)
George Hearn character Sweeney Todd (archive footage)
Beth Howland character Herself (archive footage)
Hugh Jackman character Curly (archive footage)
Glynis Johns character Herself (archive footage)
Larry Kert character Tony (archive footage)
Charles Kimbrough character Himself (archive footage)
Patti LaBelle character Herself (archive footage)
Gypsy Rose Lee character Herself (archive footage)
Jill Lord character Audience Lady
Merle Louise character Herself (archive footage)
Donna McKechnie character Herself (archive footage)
Ethel Merman character Herself (archive footage)
Donna Murphy character Fosca (archive footage)
Pamela Myers character Herself (archive footage)
Mandy Patinkin character Himself (archive footage)
Bernadette Peters character Herself (archive footage)
Teri Ralston character Herself (archive footage)
Jeffrey Schiller character Bass clarinet player
Jere Shea character Giorgio (archive footage)
Frank Sinatra character Himself (archive footage)
Barbra Streisand character Herself (archive footage)
Elaine Stritch character Herself (archive footage)
Will Swenson character Himself - Guitar Player
Eha Urbsalu character Starlet
Cher character Herself (archive footage)
