Cheryl Ladd character Mrs. Claus
George Newbern character Thomas Reynolds
Pat Finn character Santa Claus
Danny Woodburn character Eli
Obba Babatundé character Mayor Denny
Kaitlyn Maher character Sarah Reynolds
Jay Brazeau character Judge
Genevieve Hannelius character Charity (voice)
Josh Feldman character Carter Reynolds
Ali Hillis character Agnes Bright
Jennifer Elise Cox character Blue Bright
Audrey Wasilewski character Dorothy Bright
Bill Chott character Mr. Holman
Paul Rae character Jeb Gibson
Brian T. Finney character Sheriff Andy
Ted Rooney character Mr. Miller
Tom Everett Scott character Santa Paws (voice)
Bonnie Somerville character Mrs. Paws (voice)
Aidan Gemme character Noble (voice)
Tatiana Gudegast character Hope (voice)
Marlowe Peyton character Jingle (voice)
Richard Kind character Eddy (voice)
Diedrich Bader character Comet (voice)
Chris Coppola character Dancer (voice)
Josh Flitter character Brutus (voice)
Trevor Wright character Baxter (voice)
Joey Bothwell character Mildred
Bryce Clyde Jenkins character Emmett
Nic Novicki character Ellis
Michael Teigen character Mr. Kent
