Don Knotts character Dr. Jesse W. Heywood
Barbara Rhoades character Penelope 'Bad Penny' Cushings
Jackie Coogan character Matthew Basch
Ruth McDevitt character Mrs. Olive Heywood
Frank McGrath character Mr. Remington
Terry Wilson character Welsh
Carl Ballantine character Abel Swanson
Pat Morita character Wong
Robert Yuro character Arnold the Kid
Herb Voland character Dr. Friedlander
Fay DeWitt character Violet
Dub Taylor character Pop Cushings
Hope Summers character Celia
Dick Wilson character Black Eagle (Indian chief)
Don Barry character Rev. Zachary Gant
Vaughn Taylor character Rev. Longbaugh
Ed Peck character Sheriff
Edward Faulkner character Marshal Sam Huggins
Arthur Space character Sheriff Tolliver
Greg Mullavey character Phelps - Dental Student
Fred Aldrich character Passerby (uncredited)
E.J. André character Will Banks (uncredited)
John Aniston character Indian (uncredited)
Argentina Brunetti character Squaw (uncredited)
Claudia Bryar character Mrs. Remington (uncredited)
Paul Bryar character Man at Bar (uncredited)
Noble Chissell character Townsman (uncredited)
William Christopher character Hotel Manager (uncredited)
Frank Coghlan Jr. character Man at Bar (uncredited)
Warde Donovan character Townsman (uncredited)
Mickey Finn character Father (uncredited)
Myron Healey character Stage Passenger (uncredited)
Charles Horvath character Indian Warrior (uncredited)
Clyde Howdy character Man (uncredited)
I. Stanford Jolley character Bearded Stage Passenger (uncredited)
Gil Lamb character Slosh White - Drunk (uncredited)
James McHale character Conductor (uncredited)
Tina Menard character Squaw (uncredited)
Kathryn Minner character 96-Year-Old Woman (uncredited)
Dorothy Neumann character Mrs. Eva Longbaugh (uncredited)
Eddie Quillan character Train Porter (uncredited)
Bill Quinn character U.S. Marshal Arthur Bates (uncredited)
Rodd Redwing character White Buffalo (uncredited)
Benny Rubin character Man at Bar (uncredited)
Naomi Stevens character Squaw (uncredited)
Boyd Stockman character Stage Driver (uncredited)
Leonard Stone character Bartender (uncredited)
Lorna Thayer character Saloon Girl (uncredited)
Peggy Mondo character Indian Woman in Stagecoach
