Vincent Price character Charles Dexter Ward / Joseph Curwen
Debra Paget character Ann Ward
Lon Chaney Jr. character Simon Orne
Frank Maxwell character Dr. Marinus Willet / Priam Willet
Leo Gordon character Edgar Weeden / Ezra Weeden
Elisha Cook Jr. character Gideon Smith / Micah Smith
John Dierkes character Benjamin West / Jacob West
Milton Parsons character Jabez Hutchinson
Cathie Merchant character Hester Tillinghast
Guy Wilkerson character Gideon Leach / Mr. Leach
Barboura Morris character Mrs. Weeden
I. Stanford Jolley character Carmody, Coachman
Harry Ellerbe character Minister
Darlene Lucht character Miss Fitch
Bruno VeSota character Bruno, the Bartender
Jack Tornek character Lynch Mob Member (uncredited)
