Ryan Reynolds character George Lutz
Melissa George character Kathy Lutz
Jesse James character Billy Lutz
Jimmy Bennett character Michael Lutz
Chloë Grace Moretz character Chelsea Lutz
Rachel Nichols character Lisa
Philip Baker Hall character Father Callaway
Isabel Conner character Jodie Defeo
Brendan Donaldson character Ronald Defeo
Annabel Armour character Realtor
Rich Komenich character Chief of Police
David Gee character ER Doctor
Danny McCarthy character Officer Greguski
Nancy Lollar character Librarian
José Taitano character Stitch
Lenore Thomas character Nurse Fuller
Marie Joelyn character Store Patron
Dorian Kingi character Scary Leashed Indian
Alan Koeppen character Paramedic
Ryan Kross character Restaurant patron
Sam Raysby character New York State Trooper
Jenny Strubin character Grocery Cashier
