Brad Pitt character Michael Sullivan
Robert De Niro character Father Bobby
Kevin Bacon character Sean Nokes
Jason Patric character Lorenzo 'Shakes' Carcaterra
Ron Eldard character John Reilly
Billy Crudup character Tommy Marcano
Dustin Hoffman character Danny Snyder
Minnie Driver character Carol Martinez
Brad Renfro character Young Michael Sullivan
Vittorio Gassman character King Benny
Joe Perrino character Young Lorenzo 'Shakes' Carcaterra
Jonathan Tucker character Young Tommy Marcano
Geoffrey Wigdor character Young John Reilly
Terry Kinney character Ralph Ferguson
Bruno Kirby character Shakes' Father
Eugene Byrd character Rizzo
Frank Medrano character Fat Mancho
Ruth Maleczech character Woman at Subway Station
Tom Signorelli character Confessional Man
Jeffrey Donovan character Addison
Lennie Loftin character Styler
Wendell Pierce character Little Caesar
James Pickens Jr. character Marlboro
Danny Mastrogiorgio character Nick Davenport
Peter Rini character Frank Magciccio
John Slattery character Carlson
Dash Mihok character K.C.
Sean Patrick Reilly character Young King Benny
Saverio Guerra character Man #1
Larry Romano character Man #2
Aida Turturro character Mrs. Salinas
Chuck Low character Judge
Michael P. Moran character Judge
Peter Appel character Boyfriend
Paul Herman character Court Bailiff
John Di Benedetto character Tony
Robert W. Castle character Priest
