Edward Norton character Bill Kincaid / Brady Kincaid
Susan Sarandon character Daisy Kincaid
Richard Dreyfuss character Pug Rothbaum
Keri Russell character Janet
Melanie Lynskey character Colleen
Lucy DeVito character Anne Greenstein
Kent Jude Bernard character Philosophy Student
Amelia Campbell character Maggie Harmon
Tim Blake Nelson character Bolger
Randal Reeder character Shaver
Leo Fabian character Waddell
Pruitt Taylor Vince character Big Joe Sharpe
Tina Parker character Sharon
Ty Burrell character Professor Sorenson
Lee Wilkof character Professor Nathan Levy
Josh Pais character Ken Feinman
Lisa Benavides character Suzie Feinman
Steven E. Williams character Synagogue Parishioner (uncredited)
Maggie Siff character Rabbi Zimmerman
Tim Ware character Minister Davies
Ken Cheeseman character Jimmy Fuller
Steve Earle character Buddy Fuller
Lee Wilkof character Professor Levy
