Logan Lerman character Marcus Messner
Sarah Gadon character Olivia Hutton
Tracy Letts character Dean Caudwell
Linda Emond character Esther Messner
Joanne Baron character Mrs. Greenberg
Ben Rosenfield character Bertram Flusser
Philip Ettinger character Ron Foxman
Pico Alexander character Sonny Cottler
Noah Robbins character Marty Ziegler
Danny Burstein character Max Messner
Susan Varon character Mrs. Dadidovich
Bryan Burton character Ben
Steven Kaplan character Anker
Richard Topol character Mo Greenberg
Isabel Keating character Miss Clement
Eli Gelb character David
Margo Kazaryan character Student
Doris McCarthy character Church Volunteer
Melanie Blake Roth character Student
Andrew S. Thompson character Student
Bo Stansell character Young Nurse
Bryan Fitzgerald character History Student
Betsy Hogg character Sophomore Girl
Rebecca Watson character College Nurse
Will MacAdam character Family Friend at Shiva & Synagogue
Jason Erik Zacek character Student
Kc Coy character College Student
Samuel Dunning character Dead American Soldier
Eliza Foss character Alice
Ruth Flaherty character Church Matron
Tom Bair character President Wentz
Sam Rohloff character Dead American Soldier
Neal Arluck character Man In Synagogue
