Jesse Metcalfe character Tom Endler
Robin Givens character Principal Kinney
Melissa Joan Hart character Grace Wesley
Brad Heller character School Attorney
Ernie Hudson character Judge Stennis
Hayley Orrantia character Brooke Thawley
Pat Boone character Walter Wesley
Paul Kwo character Martin Yip
Trisha LaFache character Amy Ryan
Jon Lindstrom character Superintendent Jim Powell
Maria Canals-Barrera character Catherine Thawley
Benjamin A. Onyango character Reverend Jude
Sadie Robertson character Marlene
Carey Scott character Richard Thawley
Fred Dalton Thompson character Senior Pastor
David A.R. White character Pastor Dave Hill
Ray Wise character Peter Kane
Tommy Blaze character Waiter
Rice Broocks character Rice Broocks
Mallory Hardin Brooks character Susan Stone
Natalie Canerday character Mrs. Rizzo
Ron Clemens character Rev. Dave Double
Verda Davenport character First Teacher
Abigail Duhon character Jessica
Taylor Eaves character Goth Girl
Kayla Esmond character Crazy Cat Lady
Mary Faulkner character Frazzled Teacher
Jenn Gotzon Chandler character Fashionista
Gary Habermas character Gary Habermas
Lauren Harper character Sunny Barista
Candyce Hinkle character Salvation Army Lady
Mike Huckabee character Mike Huckabee
Andres Hudson character Bailiff
Mark Whitman Johnson character County Clerk
Corey Koteras character Slacker Kid
Mario Luna character Prospective Juror
Travis McCoy character Male Journalist
Eamonn McCrystal character Simon Boyle
Gary Newton character Paramedic
Vivian Norman character Norma
Chanley Painter character V.P. of Teachers Union
Taylor Quick character Teenage Girl
Paige Martin Reynolds character Pharmacist
Kimberly Scott character Female Juror
Gianna Simone character Elizabeth Healy
John Stiritz character Older Man
Lee Strobel character Lee Strobel
Ryk St. Vincent character Jury Forman
J. Warner Wallace character Jim Warner Wallace
Jesse Wang character Martin's Father
Michael Tait character The Newsboys
Duncan Phillips character The Newsboys
Jeff Frankenstein character The Newsboys
Jody Davis character The Newsboys
Cara Alvey character Concert Patron (uncredited)
Danny Campbell character Jury Extra (uncredited)
Gregory Chisley character Courtroom observer (uncredited)
Brock Clyburn character Medical Staff (uncredited)
Ann Cogswell character Food Truck Patron (uncredited)
Margaret Cogswell character Gallery Observer (uncredited)
Greg Fallon character Lawyer (uncredited)
Kenneth Gaddie character Protestor (uncredited)
Latiera Golliday character Waitress (uncredited)
Lauren Hall character Extra (uncredited)
Mary Handiboe character Courtroom Observer (uncredited)
Bryan Harp character Paramedic (uncredited)
Spencer Kane Hess character Student (trouble maker) (uncredited)
Brent Holt character Protester Shaking Jesse Metcalfe Hand (uncredited)
Misty Jezierski character Supporter (uncredited)
D. Matt Jordan character Juror #6 (uncredited)
Chuck King character Background (uncredited)
James Mainard O'Connell character Timid Pastor (uncredited)
Star McCann character Courtroom Observer / Protester (uncredited)
Angela Sherrill Merriott character Courtroom Observer (uncredited)
Alanna Hamill Newton character Juror (uncredited)
Carmen Patterson character Courtroom Gallery / Protestor (uncredited)
Arnold John Popa III character Courtroom Observer / Reporter (uncredited)
Nicole A. Randall character Concert patron (uncredited)
Nokona Redus character Classmate (uncredited)
Ashley Richardson character Extra (uncredited)
Taylor Robirts character Protester (uncredited)
Samantha M Shaw character Protester (uncredited)
Isaac Slatton character Protester (uncredited)
Shawn C Smith character Concert Attendee (uncredited)
Kristina Strava character Concert Patron (uncredited)
Cameron Taylor character Lawyer Assistant (uncredited)
Stacey McBryde Valley character Extra (uncredited)
Mindy Van Kuren character Reporter (uncredited)
Terri Whitehurst character Concert Patron (uncredited)
Don E. Willis character Extra (uncredited)
