Gillian Jacobs character Leslie
John Malkovich character Michael
Ryan Simpkins character Young Leslie
Tom Arnold character Alex
Kevin Zegers character Frank
Jermaine Scooter Smith character Young Donnie
Harold Perrineau character Orlando
Jeremy Sisto character Jimmy
Raynold Gideon character Judge Feeney
Cornelia Guest character Mrs. Feeney
Natalie May character Judge's Daughter
Ben Lin character Pa
Alice Lo character Ma
Evan Ross character Donnie
Landall Goolsby character Blackberry John
Raphael Sbarge character Mr. Whitehead
Evan Peters character Rachel / Brian
Kyle Gallner character Ratboy
Ty Simpkins character Dylan Whitehead
