Tim Allen character Brad
Kirstie Alley character Caroline
Wayne Knight character Bob Lachman
Larry Miller character Inspector Derek Lester
Jay O. Sanders character Samuel Yoder
Michael Lerner character Phil Kleinman
Miguel A. Núñez, Jr. character IRS Insp. Frank Hall
Megan Cavanagh character Levinia Yoder
John Pyper-Ferguson character Henner Lapp
Carrie Preston character Rebecca Yoder
Ethan Phillips character Jerry - Good Guys Realty
John Caponera character Dave - Good Guys Realty
Bobby Steggert character Samuel Yoder Jr.
Michael Angarano character Sammy Yoder
Rosemary Knower character Grandma Yoder
David Harscheid character Grandpa Yoder
June Claman character Judge Joan Northcutt
Marla Maples character Cynthia
Holly Cross Vagley character Mary
Crystal Bock character Penny, Brad's Secretary
Monica Deeter character Hannah Yoder
Richard Pelzman character Jonathan Yoder
Madeline Mager character Sarah
Terrence Currier character Elder Joseph
Hal Handerson character Elder Thomas
Michael Howell character Bailiff
Johanna Cox character Emma Yoder
Stefan Aleksander character Jacob Yoder
Holly Atkinson character Bank Teller
Emily Chamberlain character Evelyn, Phil's Secretary
Anthony Azizi character Malik the Cabbie
David Maples character IRS Agent
Markus Flanagan character George
Wes Johnson character Tourist
Rick Foucheux character Tom
Drenda Spohnholtz character Waitress
Marla Sucharetza character Stacy
Kirk Alexander character Young Amish Man (uncredited)
Kurt Gerard character Amish Dancer (uncredited)
Natasha Gill character Runway Model (uncredited)
Mandy Kriss character Amish Woman (uncredited)
John Michaelson character Champagne Waiter (uncredited)
Mark Norris character Police Officer (uncredited)
LauraLee O'Shell character New York Socialite (uncredited)
Bryan Spicer character Prisoner (uncredited)
Nick Stellate character Stockbroker (uncredited)
David Scott Taylor character Amish Elder (uncredited)
Tom Templeton character New Yorker (uncredited)
Katie Moore character Anna Yoder
