Lucy Hale character Lily Weil
Kathryn Prescott character Chloe Daniels
Alexandra Shipp character Amelia Bergbaum-Goldstein
Awkwafina character Rebecca Voller
Alex Wolff character Noah
Jerry MacKinnon character Sam
Michaela Watkins character Jill Weil
Austin Abrams character James Weil
Austin Butler character Thomas Daniels
Brooke Smith character Lorraine Daniels
Ronen Rubinstein character Mike
Satya Bhabha character Immanuel Bemis
Sydney Lucas character Olivia Weil
Nora Dunn character Rosa
Ian Gomez character Jerry
Colton Dunn character Officer Higgins
Jack McBrayer character Guy
Sasha Spielberg character Carrie
D.C. Pierson character Biff
Claudia Doumit character Jessica
Matt Corboy character Officer Clark
Artemis Pebdani character Sapphire
Esther Povitsky character Alicia
Stony Blyden character Stony
Gracie Watrous character Rose
Alana Baer character Anna
Sabina Friedman-Seitz character Katie B
Hayden Tweedie character Goalie
Chelsea O'Toole character Shot Girl
Stephon Fuller character Soccer Ref
Dana Williams character Crooner
Easton Alexeyev character Soccer Player (uncredited)
David S. Robinson Hicks character High School Student (uncredited)
