Hilarie Burton character Katherine
Tyler Hilton character Caleb
Randy Travis character Mr. Greenhall
Markie Post character Lilly
Edward Asner character Papa Noel
Brody Rose character Zach
Ariana Neal character Sienna
Cannon Bosarge character Bryce
Griff Furst character Josh
Colin Bates character Young Caleb
Samantha Beaulieu character Park Ranger Beth
Jacob Etter character Flashback Kid
Odessa Feaster character Local Woman
Dana Gourrier character Janelle
Leticia Jimenez character Kathryn's Assistant
Mary Katherine Oglesby character Young Katherine
Lisa Raziano character Pageant Attendee
Angela M. Thomas character Receptionist
Allen Boudreaux character Store Patron (uncredited)
John C. Coffman character Office Worker (uncredited)
Jay Florsheim character Bonfire Goer (uncredited)
Bria Hobgood character Extra (uncredited)
Tommy Sheppard character Bonfire Goer (uncredited)
