Robert De Niro character Paul Vitti
Billy Crystal character Dr. Ben Sobel
Lisa Kudrow character Laura MacNamara Sobel
Chazz Palminteri character Primo Sidone
Joe Viterelli character Jelly
Molly Shannon character Caroline
Kresh Novakovic character '50s Gangster
Bart Tangredi character Young Vitti Sr.
Michael Straka character Young Dominic Manetta
Kyle Sabihy character Michael Sobel
Frank Pietrangolare character Tuna
Ron Madoff character Extra Sea World Scene
Leo Rossi character Carlo Mangano
Donna Marie Recco character Sheila
Joseph Rigano character Dominic Manetta
Max Casella character Nicky Shivers
Bill Macy character Dr. Isaac Sobel
Jimmie Ray Weeks character FBI Agent Steadman
Tony Darrow character Moony
Gene Ruffini character Frankie Zello
Richard C. Castellano character Jimmy Boots
Frank Aquilino character Eddie 'Cokes'