Seth MacFarlane character Albert Stark
Charlize Theron character Anna
Liam Neeson character Clinch
Amanda Seyfried character Louise
Neil Patrick Harris character Foy
Giovanni Ribisi character Edward
Sarah Silverman character Ruth
Evan Jones character Lewis
Rex Linn character Sheriff / Narrator
Alex Borstein character Millie
Aaron McPherson character Ben
Christopher Hagen character George Stark
Ralph Garman character Dan
Wes Studi character Cochise
Matt Clark character Old Prospector
Brett Rickaby character Charlie Blanche
John Aylward character Pastor Wilson
Jay Patterson character Doctor Harper
Amick Byram character Marcus Thornton
Dennis Haskins character Snake Oil Salesman
Gilbert Gottfried character Abraham Lincoln
Ewan McGregor character Cowboy at Fair
John Michael Higgins character Dandy #1
Julius Sharpe character Dandy #2
Mike Miller character Vendor
Ardy Brent Carlson character Cowboay Ardy
Alec Sulkin character Guy at Fair
Tatanka Means character Other Apache
Ivan Brutsche character Angry Cowboy
Jean Effron character Elsie Stark
Bob Jesser character Cowboy at Table
Dylan Kenin character Pastor's Son
Franklin Broderick Spencer character Dirty Cowboy
Mike Salazar character 6 year old Albert
Jimmy Hart character Photographer
Allyn Rachel character Wild Girl
Joe Berryman character Teacher
Tait Fletcher character Cowboy #1
Kevin Wiggins character Ruth's Cowboy Client
Jackamoe Buzzell character Other Cowboy
Preston Bailey character 12 Year Old Albert
Belle Shouse character 12 Year Old Girl
Challen Cates character Female Passenger
Catherine Shu character Chinese Girl
Lydia Cash character Barn Dancer
Andrew Pirozzi character Barn Dancer
Kelsey Paschich character Barn Dancer
Sarah O'Gleby character Barn Dancer
Alex Wong character Barn Dancer
Vladimir Conde Reche character Barn Dancer
Jamie Foxx character Django (uncredited)
Christopher Lloyd character Doc Brown (uncredited)
Kaley Cuoco character Woman in the Store (uncredited)
Patrick Stewart character Dream Voice (uncredited)
Mae Whitman character Prostitute (uncredited)
Bill Maher character Barn Dance Comedian (uncredited)
Ryan Reynolds character Random Cowboy (uncredited)
