Candace Cameron Bure character Aurora Teagarden
Lexa Doig character Sally Allison
Marilu Henner character Aida Teagarden
Bruce Dawson character John Queensland
Peter Benson character Arthur Smith
Sonya Salomaa character Marcia Rideout
Stephen Huszar character Father Scott Aubrey
Dan Payne character Torrance Rideout
Miranda Frigon character Lynn Liggett
Fiona Vroom character Carey Osland
David Ingram character Macon Turner
Daniel Bacon character Lemaster Cane
Barbara Wallace character Jane Engles
Ellie Harvie character Lillian Tibbett
Craig March character Captain Frederick Burns
Dave Collette character Bubba Rankart
Darla Fay character Maisie Schlumper
Sean Quan character Jared
Roz Murray character Linda Turner
V.J. Delos-Reyes character Bob