Drew Barrymore character Erin Rankin Langford
Justin Long character Garrett Scully
Charlie Day character Dan Grant
Jason Sudeikis character Box Saunders
Christina Applegate character Corrine Berlin
Ron Livingston character Will Broderick
Natalie Morales character Brandy
Kelli Garner character Brianna Jutsum
Oliver Jackson-Cohen character Damon
Jim Gaffigan character Phil Berlin
June Diane Raphael character Karen Surgeoner
Rob Riggle character Ron Surgeoner
Sarah Burns character Harper
Matt Servitto character Hugh O'Keefe
Leighton Meester character Amy
Taylor Schwencke character Maya
Mike Birbiglia character Toby
Graham Davie character Zach
Zach Page character Zander
Mick Hazen character Zeff
Happy Anderson character Terry
Loretta Fox character Sandy
Carole Davis character Carmen
Kristen Schaal character Female Bartender
Terry Beaver character Professor
Charlie Hewson character Douchebag
Meredith Hagner character Tanning Salon Employee
