Paul Rudd character Paul
Steve Coogan character Erasmus
Jack Gore character Bill
Alison Pill character Melissa
Jake McDorman character Beau
Jesse Luken character Director
Lora Martinez-Cunningham character Ms. Garcia
Sarah Minnich character Crack Head Lady
Stafford Douglas character Caterer
Jacob Browne character Judge Pierce
Frances Lee McCain character Doris
Josey Smith character Whitney
Kate Walsh character Kate
Jenny Gabrielle character Betty
Monique Candelaria character Officer Guttierez
Alexandra Guarnaschelli character Alex Guarnaschelli
Courtney Cunningham character Paramedic
Drew Droege character Drew
Marie Wagenman character Little Girl
Cassandra Rochelle Fetters character Party Goer
Evan Bittencourt character Tino
Rodrigo Tactaquin character Biker
Mark Rowe character Suburban Dad
Eric Womack character Officer Forrest
Richard Beal character Church Member
Jordyn Aurora Aquino character Leticia
Clint Obenchain character Waiter
J. Nathan Simmons character Wise Man #1
Alexander Daniel Pimentel character Suburban Dad's Friend
Kristin Berg character Taco Bell Manager
Emma Armstrong character Checkout Girl
Stephen Conn character Christmas Reveler / Church decorator / Lighting tech
Michael E. Stogner character Drunk Santa (uncredited)
Amanda Quintana-Bowles character Christmas Reveler
Alison Grainger character Taco Bell Patron
Rick Tadra character Maddy
Patrick V. Murphy character Party goer
Ian Morris character Bill's Friend
Ronnie Gomez character Wise Man #3
Jeremiah Fresquez character Student #1
Viola Valdez character Parishioner
Justin Lotz character Wise Man #2
Mason Howell character Bills Friend
Sheila Eden character Tango Wife (uncredited)
Sylvie Grontis Hagan character Teacher (uncredited)
Amy Emily Stack character Inmate Visitor (uncredited)
