Robin Williams character Peter Banning
Dustin Hoffman character Captain James S. Hook
Julia Roberts character Tinkerbell
Bob Hoskins character Smee
Maggie Smith character Granny Wendy
Caroline Goodall character Moira Banning
Charlie Korsmo character Jack 'Jackie' Banning
Amber Scott character Maggie Banning
Arthur Malet character Tootles
Isaiah Robinson character Pockets
Gwyneth Paltrow character Young Wendy
Phil Collins character Inspector Good
Glenn Close character Gutless
Regina Russell Banali character Mermaid
Jasen Fisher character Ace
James Madio character Don't Ask
Ryan Francis character Young Peter Pan
Max Hoffman character 5-Year-Old Peter Pan
Kelly Rowan character Peter's Mother
Jake Hoffman character LittleLeague Player
Geoffrey Lower character Brad
Don S. Davis character Dr. Fields
Brad Blumenthal character Jim
David Crosby character Tickles
Nick Tate character Noodler
Tony Burton character Bill Jukes
Carrie Fisher character Woman Kissing on Bridge (uncredited)
George Lucas character Man Kissing on Bridge (uncredited)
Jimmy Buffett character Shoe-Stealing Pirate (uncredited)
Dante Basco character Rufio
Jan Cobler character Secretary