James Franco character Conrad
Natalie Portman character Laura
Kristen Wiig character Monica
Kate Mara character Lisa
Amber Tamblyn character Amanda
Jim Parrack character Paul
Abigail Spencer character Abigail
Keir Gilchrist character Michael
Thomas Mann character Lee
Rico Rodriguez character Charlie Foster
Matthew Modine character Theodore Foster
Jimmy Kimmel character Mr. Chipmunk
Tony Cox character Mr. Chubb
Bo Mitchell character Greg
Jacob Loeb character Keen
Kelsey Ford character Lila
Tyler Labine character Clete
Jack Kehler character Sheriff Mallon
Wendy Phillips character Mrs. Nighetti
Frank Birney character Edmund
Muriel Minot character Caddy
Priscilla Garita character Maricelle Foster
Tanner Buchanan character Bobby Bell
Wilmer Calderon character Barnett
Kai Lennox character Timmy
Ella Anderson character Sally
Charlie Martin character Cliff
David May character Brian
Katie Cofield character Val
June Conniff character Ophelia
Tom Paliferro character Sydney
Robert DuBois character Stu
Adam J. Harrington character Henry
Milan Johnson character Zach Cuttle
Alex Oberheide character Preston
Bryan Patrick West character Skins
Malia Pyles character Amber
Pappy Faulkner character Jimmy
Isaac Faulkner character Nate
Max Leifman character Young Conrad
Rebecca Ellen Evans character Young Lisa
Lili Brennan character Young Amanda
Jack Sochet character Conrad's Father
Toni Gaal character Greg's Mom
Bridget Bowes character Brian's Wife
Maite Pistiner character Michael’s Love Interest
Brian Lally character Therapist
Lowell Dean character Colorado Sheriff
Anthony Sherritt character Swinger
