Liam James character Solomon
Sarah Steele character Diwata
Austin P. McKenzie character Howie
Janeane Garofalo character Marie
Kal Penn character James
Roger Bart character Principal Bellingham
Wendi McLendon-Covey character Joan
Kimberly Williams-Paisley character Susan
Skylar Astin character Walter Healy
Sarah Baker character Miss Riggi
Darren Criss character Himself
Kristin Chenoweth character Herself
Cristina Franco character Oksana
Ryan Lee character Mark
Edgar Arreola character Arnett
Karen Beyer character Persuasive Speaking Judge
Orlette Cutrer character Teacher
Lucy DeVito character Lucy
Sara Thomas Easley character Nervous Freshman Girl
Sam Furman character Student
Angel Giuffria character Girl in Motorized Wheelchair
Gideon Glick character Gideon
Jessy Hughes character Goth Girl
Bradley K. Jones character Student
Jerry Leggio character Ted
Karen Kaia Livers character Nurse
Anna Margaret character Casey
David Militello character Plump Boy
Lin-Manuel Miranda character The Genie
Tara Shay Montgomery character Young Drag Queen
Robert Peters character Coach Pemberton
Nicholas James Reilly character Holy Ghost Junior
Bryce Romero character Short Kid
Jeremy Rowley character Gary Crenshaw
Ben Sanders character Student
Logan Shroyer character Hot Debater
Amitoz Singh character DI Boy
Lester Speight character Scary Bouncer
George Thagard character Mayor
Sloane Warren character Fiona Crenshaw
Rachel Wulff character Reporter
