Margaret Qualley character Sister Cathleen
Melissa Leo character Reverend Mother
Julianne Nicholson character Nora Harris
Dianna Agron character Sister Mary Grace
Morgan Saylor character Sister Evelyn
Maddie Hasson character Sister Sissy
Liana Liberato character Sister Emily
Rebecca Dayan character Sister Emanuel
Eline Powell character Sister Candace
Chelsea Lopez character Sister Charlotte
Denis O'Hare character Archbishop
Chris Zylka character Chuck Harris
Lisa Stewart character Sister Genevieve
Alyssa Brindley character Sister Kate
Hannah Renèe Jackson character Sister Anne
Marco St. John character Father Luca
Eliza Stella Mason character Cathleen, 7 Years Old
Bill Shick character Local Priest
Danny Vinson character Rob, Church Usher
Angela Fox character Sister Gloria
Neva Howell character Sister Eleanor
Sasha Mason character Cathleen, 12 Years Old
Peggy Walton-Walker character Nun Teacher
Ashley Bell character Sister Margaret
Rosemary Brown character Miss Williams
Gabe Beutel-Gunn character Nora's Boyfriend
Marshall Chapman character Sister Louisa
Lacy Hartselle character Sister Theresa (uncredited)
Kamryn Boyd character Blessed Sorrows Student (uncredited)
Lucie Carroll character Professed Nun (uncredited)
Adele Marie Pomerenke character Cathleen's Sister (uncredited)
Darla Pelton-Perez character Parent (uncredited)
Cecilia Wyle character Professed Nun (uncredited)
Joseph Wilson character Churchgoer (uncredited)
Anna Swiney character Blessed Sorrow's Student (uncredited)
Sydney Hoover character Blessed Sorrows Student (uncredited)
Kalista Dwyer character Cathleen's Sister (uncredited)
Julia Leigh character Blessed Sorrows Student (uncredited)
Laurie Pallotta character Professed Nun (uncredited)
Kaitlyn Williams character Cathleen's Sister (uncredited)
Kathy Walton character Professed Nun (uncredited)
Melissa Nyenhuis character Wedding attendee (uncredited)
Rachel Mae Moore character Cathleen's Sister (uncredited)
Jeromy Nichols character Churchgoer (uncredited)
Abram Knott character Alter Boy (uncredited)
Gabriela Contaldo character Nun (uncredited)
Nettie Kraft character Friend of Noras' (uncredited)
Juliana Dougherty character Blessed Sorrows Student (uncredited)
Sydney Harris character Blessed Sorrows Student (uncredited)
Jordan Price character Blessed Sorrows Student (uncredited)
Kirk H. Andersen character Churchgoer (uncredited)
Ashley Hargrove character Cathleen Sister Nun (uncredited)
Monty Powers character Parent of Nun (uncredited)
Jeffrey Wilkerson character Church Goer (uncredited)
Courtney Cook character 2nd Year Novice Nun 1 (uncredited)
Kerry Graul character Churchgoer (uncredited)
Jenny Revord character Professed Nun (uncredited)
Bryan Fields character Church Goer (uncredited)
David Alan Spodeck character Sister Evelyn's father (uncredited)
Kurstan Buck character Student (uncredited)
Tallie Fausnaught character Cathleen's Sister (uncredited)
Robert Happy Allen character Church Dad (uncredited)
Shelton Tison character Altar Boy (uncredited)
Carter Stewart character Cathleen's Son (uncredited)
Kadence Riggs character Churchgoer (uncredited)
Valeigh Rhiannon Alford character Catholic School Girl (uncredited)
Kylie Knott character Blessed Sorrows Student (uncredited)
Abby Harkins character Professed Nun (uncredited)
Jasmin Maya Larsen character Blessed Sorrows Student (uncredited)
Stephanie Heuer character Sister Evelyn's Mom (uncredited)
Debbie Swierk character Blessed Sorrows Nun (uncredited)
Tonya Webb character Parent / Churchgoer (uncredited)
Shelby Johnson character 2nd Year Novice 2 (uncredited)
Emma Barberi character Blessed Sorrows Student (uncredited)
Shayna-Raye Funderburk character Cathleen's Sister (uncredited)
Emma Grace Peper character Blessed Sorrows Student (uncredited)
Victoria Bradford character Novice Nun (uncredited)
Phillip Trammel character Novitiate Parent (uncredited)
