Greg Kinnear character Phil
Emily Mortimer character Alicia
Taylor Schilling character Sam
Kurt Fuller character Jerome
Bradley Whitford character Michael Fisk
Luke Wilson character Detective Welling
April Cameron character Rahel
Megan Charpentier character Molly McGuire
Sarah Dugdale character Kara Fisk
Jay Duplass character Malcolm
Robert Forster character Bing Fisk
Christina Jastrzembska character Mrs. Konwiser
Jagen Johnson character Booze Clerk
Angela Moore character Nurse
Nicole Oliver character Rosemary
William B. Davis character Father Grant
Rukiya Bernard character Nora
Peter Bryant character Cop
Kirby Morrow character Childhood Friend
Brittany Mitchell character Nurse 2 / Pizza Server
Alex Trebek character Alex Trebek
Doug Abrahams character Maître D'
