Gary Cooper character Captain Christopher Holden
Paulette Goddard character Abby
Howard Da Silva character Garth
Boris Karloff character Guyasuta, Chief of the Senecas
Cecil Kellaway character Jeremy Love
Ward Bond character John Fraser
Katherine DeMille character Hannah
Henry Wilcoxon character Captain Steele
C. Aubrey Smith character Lord Chief Justice
Victor Varconi character Captain Simeon Ecuyer
Virginia Grey character Diana
Porter Hall character Leach
Mike Mazurki character Bone
Richard Gaines character Colonel George Washington
Virginia Campbell character Mrs. John Fraser
Gavin Muir character Lieut. Fergus McKenzie
Alan Napier character Sir William Johnson
Ninetta Sunderland character Mrs. Pruitt
Marc Lawrence character Medicine Man Sioto
Jane Nigh character Evelyn
Raymond Hatton character Venango Scout
John Mylong character Colonel Henry Bouquet
George Kirby character London Astronomer Charles Mason
Leonard Carey character London Astronomer Jeremiah Dixon
Frank Wilcox character Richard Henry Lee
Davison Clark character Mr. Carroll of Virginia
Griff Barnett character Brother Andrews of Pennsylvania
Lloyd Bridges character Lieut. Hutchins
Oliver Thorndike character Lieut. Baillie
Rus Conklin character Mamaultee
Iron Eyes Cody character Red Corn
Julia Faye character Widow Swivens
Paul E. Burns character Dan McCoy
Mary Field character Maggie
Diane Wadelow character Lancashire Lass
Clarence Muse character Jason
Cecil B. DeMille character Himself - Narrator (voice) (uncredited)
