Danny DeVito character Buddy Hall
Matthew Broderick character Steve Finch
Kristin Davis character Kelly Finch
Kristin Chenoweth character Tia Hall
Alia Shawkat character Madison Finch
Dylan Blue character Carter Finch
Kelly Aldridge character Ashley Hall
Sabrina Aldridge character Emily Hall
Jorge Garcia character Wallace
Fred Armisen character Gustave
Gillian Vigman character Gerta
Ryan Devlin character Bob Murray
Sean O'Bryan character Mayor Young
Su-chin Pak character Self
Jackie Burroughs character Mrs. Ryor
Garry Chalk character Sheriff Dave
Nicola Peltz character Mackenzie
Zak Santiago character Fireworks Guy
David Lewis character Ted
Daniel Bacon character Ed
Ken Kramer character Mr. Murray
Jill Morrison character Gail
Alf Humphreys character Hardware Store Employee
Brenda Crichlow character News Reporter #1
Jill Krop character Reporter #2
Agam Darshi character News Producer
David Stuart character Oblivious Dad
Quinn Lord character Santa Kid
Nathaniel DeVeaux character Main Street Passerby #1
Fulvio Cecere character Town Passerby
Eliza Norbury character Mary in the Manger
Randi Lynne character Caroler #1
Dan Joffre character Caroler #2
Aurora Faulkner-Killam character Caroler
Melissa Howell character Caroler
Lori Johnson character Caroler
David Shaw character Caroler
Myles Wolfe character Caroler
Ty Olsson character Trucker
Stephen Holmes character UPS Guy
Andrew Hedge character City Employee
Cory Monteith character Madison's Date
Nick Balaban character Caroler (uncredited)
Shelsie Blake character Caroler (uncredited)
Aaron Craven character Businessman Dad (uncredited)
Sommer Garcia character Caroler (uncredited)
Blair Gorrell character Carnival Fan (uncredited)
Rachel Lana Li character Spectator (uncredited)
Lochlyn Munro character Ted (uncredited)
Kal Penn character Amit Sayid - Satellite Computer Tech (uncredited)
Caroline Redekopp character Mackenzie's Mother (uncredited)
Arden Rhine character Background Performer (uncredited)
Raymond Trickitt character Caroler (uncredited)
Calum Worthy character Boy on Bike (uncredited)
