Will Ferrell character Buddy
James Caan character Walter
Bob Newhart character Papa Elf
Edward Asner character Santa
Mary Steenburgen character Emily
Zooey Deschanel character Jovie
Daniel Tay character Michael
Faizon Love character Gimbel's Manager
Peter Dinklage character Miles Finch
Amy Sedaris character Deb
Michael Lerner character Fulton
Andy Richter character Morris
Kyle Gass character Eugene
Artie Lange character Gimbel's Santa
Leon Redbone character Leon the Snowman (voice)
Ray Harryhausen character Polar Bear Cub (voice)
Claire Lautier character NY 1 Reporter
Ted Friend character NY 1 Anchor
Patrick Ferrell character Security Guard
Patrick McCartney character Security Guard
Jon Favreau character Doctor
Lydia Lawson-Baird character Carolyn
Brenda McDonald character Nun
Annie Brebner character Elf Student
Luke Pohl character Elf Student
Meghan Black character Elf
Patrick Baynham character Elf
Michael Roberds character Disgruntled Cobbler Elf
Peter A. Hulne character Elf Twin
Patrick Hulne character Elf Twin
Richard Side character Elf Teacher
David Avalon character Pom Pom
Kristian Ayre character Foom Foom
Lorin Heath character Perfume Clerk
Dillard Brinson character Printer
Brad Turner character Office Co-Worker
David Berenbaum character Office Co-Worker
Brenda Crichlow character Office Co-Worker
Oscar Goncalves character Francisco
Mary Black character Nurse
Murray Jack character Man in Elevator
Mark Acheson character Mailroom Guy
Robin Mossley character Chuck
Paul Schofield character Kid with Santa
Matt Walsh character Self
Will McCormack character Witness
Gus Michael character Witness
Alexandra Michael character Child
Terry J. Scarlatos character Police Officer
Jonathan Bruce character Biker
Akeem A. Smith character School Kid
Michael Christopher Fischetti character School Kid
Jane Bradbury character Susan Welles
