Ryan Reynolds character Gary / Gavin / Gabriel
Melissa McCarthy character Margaret / Melissa / Mary
Hope Davis character Sarah / Susan / Sierra
Elle Fanning character Noelle
David Denman character Parole Officer/ Agitated Man
Octavia Spencer character Streetwalker
Ben Falcone character Himself
Dahlia Salem character Herself
John Gatins character Himself
Lorene Scafaria character Game Night Guest
