Stephanie Sigman character Sister Charlotte
Talitha Bateman character Janice
Lulu Wilson character Linda
Anthony LaPaglia character Samuel Mullins
Miranda Otto character Esther Mullins
Grace Fulton character Carol
Philippa Coulthard character Nancy
Lou Lou Safran character Tierney
Tayler Buck character Kate
Samara Lee character Annabelle "Bee" Mullins
Mark Bramhall character Father Massey
Adam Bartley character Officer Fuller
Alicia Vela-Bailey character Evil Mrs Mullins
Joseph Bishara character Annabelle Demon
Lotta Losten character Adoption agent
Brian Howe character Pete Higgins
Kerry O'Malley character Sharon Higgins
Tree O'Toole character Adult Janice / Annabelle Higgins
Annabelle Wallis character Mia Form (archive footage)
Ward Horton character John Form (archive footage)
Brad Greenquist character Victor Palmeri
Bonnie Aarons character Demon Nun
Liam James Ramos character Small Boy
Karalee Austin character Church Member
Tyler A. Johnson character Priest Holding Annabelle
