Zac Efron character Ted Bundy
Lily Collins character Liz Kendall
Kaya Scodelario character Carole Anne Boone
John Malkovich character Judge Edward Cowart
Jim Parsons character Larry Simpson
Angela Sarafyan character Joanna
Haley Joel Osment character Jerry
Grace Victoria Cox character Carol Daronch
Forba Shepherd character Louise Bundy
Grace Balbo character Teenage Molly
Morgan Pyle character 8 Yr Old Molly
Ava Inman character 4 Yr Old Molly
Macie Carmosino character 2 Yr Old Molly
Sydney Vollmer character Babysitter
Ken Strunk character Colorado Judge George Lohr
Joe Berlinger character Colorado Jailhouse Reporter
Brandon Trost character Colorado Jailhouse Cameraman
Jared Joplin character Colorado District Attorney Frank Tucker
Justin McCombs character Colorado Defense Attorney Jim Dumas
Tim Young character Colorado Jailhouse Boom Op
Jeffrey Donovan character Utah Defense Attorney John O'Connell
Dylan Baker character Utah Prosecutor David Yocom
Brian Geraghty character Dan Dowd
Terry Kinney character Detective Mike Fisher
James Hetfield character Officer Bob Hayward
Torrie Wiggins character Woman with Dog
Kevin McClatchy character Ken Katsaris
Rajiim A. Gross character Metro Justice News Journalist
Calvin David Jones III character Utah Prisioner
Aaron Cool character Metro Justice News Journalist
Leilani Barrett character Liz's Boss
Ally Sereda character Liz's Secretary
Richard K. Jones character Interrogation Room Sheriff
Justin Inman character Police Lineup Suspect
Alan B. Jones character Utah Judge Stewart Hanson
Maya Berlinger character Concerned Library Co-Ed
Derek Snow character Security Guard
Ryan Wesley Gilreath character Deputy Westerlund
Chris Petty character Officer David Lee
Tony L. Winstead character Extra
Ming Wang character Court Clerk Shirley Lewis
James Siderits character Prisoner's Attorney (uncredited)
