Tim Allen character Scott Calvin / Santa / Toy Santa
Elizabeth Mitchell character Carol Newman
David Krumholtz character Bernard
Eric Lloyd character Charlie Calvin
Judge Reinhold character Neil Miller
Wendy Crewson character Laura Miller
Spencer Breslin character Curtis
Liliana Mumy character Lucy Miller
Danielle Woodman character Abby
Art LaFleur character Tooth Fairy
Aisha Tyler character Mother Nature
Kevin Pollak character Cupid
Jay Thomas character Easter Bunny
Michael Dorn character Sandman
Christopher Attadia character Engineer Elf #1
Curtis Butchart character Elf Center
Jamal Allen character Elf Quarterback
Alexander Pollock character Richie / Elf Tight End
Bryce Hodgson character Engineer Elf #2
Molly Shannon character Tracy
Carmen Aguirre character Spanish Teacher
Leanne Adachi character Grace
Blu Mankuma character John Pierce
Andrew Stone character Picardo
Kenya Jo Kennedy character Pamela
Janne Mortil character Pamela's Mother
Alexandra Purvis character Danielle
Fred Keating character Security Guard
Fred Ewanuick character Seismic Interpreter
Dan Joffre character C-130 Pilot
J. B. Bivens character Engineer
Alexander Hoy character Elf with Kangaroo
Bart Anderson character Hangdog Teacher
Beverley Elliott character Female Teacher
D. Neil Mark character Teacher
Ted Cole character Teacher
Nicole Leroux character Teacher
Michael P. Northey character Teacher
Alejandro Abellan character Teacher
June B. Wilde character Teacher
Charles Payne character Teacher
Gary Jones character Teacher
Victor Brandt character Reindeer
Kath Soucie character Voice of Chet (voice)
Bob Bergen character Voice of Comet (voice)
Nicola Anderson character Blind Date (uncredited)
Anysha Berthot character Molly Elf (uncredited)
Peter Boyle character Father Time (uncredited)
Caroline Chan character Elf (uncredited)
Patrick Dorn character Elf (uncredited)
Paul Hooson character Reindeer (uncredited)
Ryan James character Elf (uncredited)
Myles Jeffrey character Elf (uncredited)
Connor Matheus character Elf (uncredited)
Justine Nguyen character Baker's Elf / Bridesmaid (uncredited)
Valerie Tian character Elf (uncredited)
Michael S. Weir character Restaurant Patron (uncredited)
Vinicius Zorin-Machado character Restaurant Patron (uncredited)
Beatrice Zeilinger character Teacher
