Billy Eichner character Bobby Leiber
Luke Macfarlane character Aaron
Guy Branum character Henry
Miss Lawrence character Wanda
Ts Madison character Angela
Dot-Marie Jones character Cherry
Jim Rash character Robert
Eve Lindley character Tamara
Monica Raymund character Tina
Guillermo Díaz character Edgar
Jai Rodriguez character Jason
Amanda Bearse character Anne
Debra Messing character Debra Messing
Peter Y. Kim character Peter
Justin Covington character Paul
Symone character Marty
Ryan Faucett character Josh Evans
Becca Blackwell character Lucas
D'Lo character Tom
Bowen Yang character Lawrence Grape
Harvey Fierstein character Lewis
Brock Ciarlelli character Steve
Kristin Chenoweth character Kristin Chenoweth
Matthew Wilkas character Handsome Grindr Guy
Dahlia Rodriguez character Hannah
Derrick Delgado character Brian
George Dvorsky character Bruce
Jamyl Dobson character Joel
Ben Stiller character Ben Stiller (uncredited)
Kenan Thompson character James Baldwin
Amy Schumer character Eleanor Roosevelt
Seth Meyers character Harvey Milk (uncredited)
Jillian Gottlieb character Samantha
Rick Crom character Grape's Neighbor
Everett Quinton character Melvin Funk
Anthony DeVito character Liberal Dad
Alex Ringler character Baseball Player's Man
Joanne Lamstein character Straight Liberal Mom (uncredited)
