Rachel McAdams character Barbara Simon
Abby Ryder Fortson character Margaret Simon
Kathy Bates character Sylvia Simon
Elle Graham character Nancy Wheeler
Benny Safdie character Herbert Simon
Amari Alexis Price character Janie Loomis
Katherine Mallen Kupferer character Gretchen Potter
Kate MacCluggage character Mrs. Jan Wheeler
Aidan Wojtak-Hissong character Moose Freed
Landon S. Baxter character Evan Wheeler
Echo Kellum character Mr. Benedict
Mia Dillon character Mary Hutchins
Gary Houston character Paul Hutchins
Mackenzie Joy Potter character Mamma Bunny
Olivia Williams character Witch
Mike Platarote Jr. character Guy in Car
Simms May character Norman Fisher
Zack Brooks character Philip Leroy
JeCobi Swain character Freddy Barnett
Wilbur Fitzgerald character Morris Binamin
Ethan McDowell character Mr. Wheeler
Sloane Warren character Mrs. Fisher
Isol Young character Laura Danker
Eden Lee character PTA Mother
Naida Nelson character PTA Mother
Tahirah Harrison character PTA Mother
Zach Humphrey character Salvation Army Guy
Karen Aruj character Department Store Sales Lady
Judy Blume character Neighbor Walking Dog #1
George Cooper character Neighbor Walking Dog #2
Joan Jackson character Neighbor
Stephen Jackson character Neighbor
Robert Haulbrook character Rough Looking Guy on Bus
Johnny Land character The General
Jennifer Errington character New York Restaurant Waitress
Evan Bergman character Greg the Greeter
Michael Wolk character Rabbi Kellerman
Karen Macarah character Cantor
Ariel DiDonato character Aliyah
Claude Deuce character Gospel Singer / Pastor
Keya Hamilton character Gospel Singer
Tanya J. McClellan character Mrs. Loomis
Dennis Delamar character Mailman
Samantha LeBrocq character Mrs. Potter
Wally White character Protestant Minister
Holli Saperstein character Mrs. Webster
Deborah Helms character Sweet Old Lady Cashier
Cooper Herrett character 17 Year Old Cashier
Gezell Fleming character School Librarian
Jim France character Catholic Priest
Rakeem Massingill character Art Student
Ian Ottis Goff character Margaret Body Double
